In the shadows of history, where the extraordinary often intertwines with the mundane, the story of Isidor Straus unfolds—a tale of ambition, adversity, and an untimely end aboard the ill-fated Titanic. Born in 1845 in the serene Palatinate region, under the Kingdom of Bavaria’s rule, Isidor’s early life was a mosaic of cultural richness and upheaval.
His birthplace, Otterberg, cradled him in tradition, while his Jewish family, led by Lazarus and Sara Straus, were prominent businesspeople.
The Straus family, including Isidor’s siblings Hermine, Nathan, Jakob Otto, and Oscar Solomon, faced the winds of change head-on. In 1854, their journey turned pivotal as they crossed the Atlantic, seeking new horizons in the United States. Columbus, Georgia, welcomed them initially, but it was in Talbotton, Georgia, where they planted deeper roots.
Yet, fate had other plans. The American Civil War Isidor’s trajectory. West Point’s military discipline and strategy remained an unfulfilled aspiration as the war’s chaos engulfed him. Young and restless, Isidor was elected as an officer in a Confederate unit, only to be sidelined by his youth. Undeterred, he voyaged to England, immersing himself in clandestine activities as a Confederate aide and bond salesman.
Ida Straus with her husband Isidor Straus
Post-war, the Straus family, now ensconced in the bustling metropolis of New York City, embarked on a venture that would redefine retail history. Persuading Rowland Hussey Macy to open their doors to L. Straus & Sons marked a turning point. This humble crockery department in Macy’s basement blossomed into a thriving enterprise, mirroring the city’s metamorphosis.
Isidor, alongside his brother Nathan, navigated this burgeoning business landscape with acumen and vision. Their partnership with Macy’s in 1888 was merely the beginning. The purchase of Wechsler & Straus, which later became Abraham & Straus, and the eventual full ownership of R. H. Macy & Co. in 1896 were significant turning points in a journey characterized by tenacity and innovation.
Yet, for all his commercial triumphs, Isidor Straus’ story is tinged with a poignant finality. Aboard the Titanic, Isidor and his wife, Ida, embraced their destiny together. This is what he would be known for.
Isador Straus on the Titanic
Isidor and Ida Straus returned from their European vacation during the winter of 1912, which included relaxing days in the tranquil surroundings of Cape Martin in southern France. Their passage aboard the Titanic was not just a return journey but a voyage into history, etching their names indelibly in the archives of time.
On the night of April 14, as the clock neared 11:40 p.m., their world—and that of every soul aboard the Titanic—was irrevocably altered. The ship’s collision with an iceberg set a tragic sequence of events in motion. Amidst the ensuing pandemonium, as it became evident that the Titanic’s fate was sealed, the bond between Isidor and Ida Straus transcended all fears and societal norms.
Ida’s steadfast refusal to leave Isidor, even with the possibility of escape, spoke volumes of their inseparable bond. This unwavering commitment was further exemplified in the testimony of Colonel Archibald Gracie IV, a friend and Titanic survivor. Despite suggesting that Isidor could accompany her in a lifeboat, Ida’s determination remained firm. Her declaration, “I will not be separated from my husband. As we have lived, so will we die together,” echoed a deep-rooted fidelity and dedication. In a final act of selflessness, Ida entrusted her fur coat to her maid, insisting on her safety and asking her to go on the lifeboat.
Isidor Straus (Lew Palter) with his wife, during the dinner in Titanic (1997)
The couple’s final moments united on the deck, were observed by eyewitnesses as a profound display of love and devotion. The Titanic ultimately sank at 2:20 a.m. Following the incident, CS Mackay-Bennett retrieved Isidor’s body and sent it to Halifax, Nova Scotia, before delivering it to New York.
He was laid to rest in the Straus-Kohns Mausoleum at Beth-El Cemetery in Brooklyn and later reinterred in the Straus Mausoleum at Woodlawn Cemetery in the Bronx in 1928.
Tragically, Ida’s body was never recovered. In remembrance, the family placed water from the Titanic’s final resting place in an urn within the mausoleum. A cenotaph outside the mausoleum bears a poignant inscription from the Song of Solomon (8:7), “Many waters cannot quench love—neither can the floods drown it,” serving as an enduring tribute to Isidor and Ida’s undying love.
Isador and Ida Straus Depiction in Movies
The poignant story of Isidor and Ida Straus has been portrayed in various cinematic adaptations, each interpreting their final moments with differing degrees of historical accuracy and artistic license.
In the 1953 film “Titanic,” as well as the 1958 film “A Night to Remember,” and the stage musical “Titanic,” the depiction of the couple adheres closely to the well-documented accounts of their last hours. These portrayals resonate with the authenticity of their unwavering commitment to each other in the face of impending doom.
Isidor Straus in the 1997 Film Titanic deleted scene Ida Straus won’t leave
However, the 1979 film “S.O.S. Titanic” differs from the historical narrative. In this rendition, Ida informs Isidor of her intention to “stay a little while,” a departure from the established narrative of her resolute decision to remain by his side.
The 1997 blockbuster “Titanic” offers a brief but poignant glimpse of the Strauss, though it takes creative liberties. Contrary to historical evidence that Isidor’s body was recovered and there being no confirmation of their return to their cabin, the film depicts them in an embrace, sharing a kiss on their bed as their stateroom floods. This scene, set to the emotive backdrop of the ship’s string quartet playing “Nearer My God to Thee,” adds a layer of dramatic intensity to the unfolding tragedy.
Additionally, in a cut scene from the same movie that more closely matches survivor accounts, Isidor (played by Lew Palter) tries to persuade Ida (Elsa Raven) to get on a lifeboat, but she stubbornly refuses.
Though not included in the final cut, this scene offers a narrative more in tune with the historical events as they are understood.
Ida and Isidor perish together in their stateroom.
Each of these cinematic interpretations brings to life the enduring legacy of Isidor and Ida Straus, capturing the essence of their love and devotion amidst one of history’s most tragic maritime disasters.
Next, read about the Story of the Delphi Murders and how the real monsters could still be hiding. Then, about the Disturbing Secrets of the Bohemian Grove!
